welcome: please sign in

Diff for "WikiReplacement2021"

Differences between revisions 9 and 10
Revision 9 as of 2021-03-02 13:51:08
Size: 2809
Editor: KevinEverets
Comment: Add Phriction as an option
Revision 10 as of 2021-03-31 22:12:38
Size: 3089
Editor: JesseShumway
Comment: Added DokuWiki
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 82: Line 82:
See also [[https://bloodhound.apache.org/|Apache Bloodhound]]  See also [[https://bloodhound.apache.org/|Apache Bloodhound]]
Line 89: Line 89:

==== DokuWiki ====

 * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DokuWiki
 * Implemented in PHP 7 and jQuery 3
 * Packeged in current Debian
 * Lastest release 07/2020
 * Flat-file storage in file system
 * ACLs, full text search, plug-ins, templates
 * MediaWiki/PHPwiki syntax

1. Background

We are currently using moinmoin version 1.9 for this wiki. Version 1.9 requires Python 2.7 which is no longer developed by Python upstream, and will not be available in future Debian releases. Moinmoin 2 solves that and had many other improvements, but it is still in development.

2. Features

2.1. Current

  • Not tied to HCoop accounts, and anyone can create an account
  • TextCHA for spam prevention

  • Domtool/installer help for member's own installations
  • Filesystem storage

2.2. Desired

  • Current content can be migrated
  • Actively developed
  • Ability to use hcoop account to reduce need for additional login/account

2.3. Options

See also Wikipedia's wiki comparison

2.3.1. Gitit

2.3.2. Gollum

2.3.3. ikiwiki

2.3.4. MediaWiki

2.3.5. Moinmoin under Tauthon

Tauthon is a fork of Python 2 that is actively developed. It maintains backwards compatibility with Python 2 while adding language features from Python 3 in a backwards compatible way. We could run moinmoin 1.9 with Tauthon. It is currently not packaged for Debian.

2.3.6. OddMuse

2.3.7. Phriction

2.3.8. SourceHut

  • https://man.sr.ht/

  • Implemented in Python
  • Markdown syntax
  • Git (or Mercurial?) storage
  • Also has an issue tracker, mailing list, repository hosting (git/hg), and CI — in a modular design; parts can be mixed/matched.
  • Philosophically aligned (Software Freedom values)
  • Editing exclusively through version control (PRs via email patches).

2.3.9. Trac

2.3.10. XWiki

2.3.11. DokuWiki

  • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DokuWiki

  • Implemented in PHP 7 and jQuery 3
  • Packeged in current Debian
  • Lastest release 07/2020
  • Flat-file storage in file system
  • ACLs, full text search, plug-ins, templates
  • MediaWiki/PHPwiki syntax

WikiReplacement2021 (last edited 2021-03-31 22:12:38 by JesseShumway)